Example data. Made-up numbers to show what a report looks like. Not a real customer, dealer, or quote.
Deal Assessment Do not sign as written
Serious problems. Don't sign this as written.
3 to fix 3 to ask about 2 look right 1 need info
- Negotiating room
- 3 items to raise (largest: $899.00 saved if you decline it).
- Fees to challenge
- Nothing flagged in what we could check.
- Finance terms
- 3 items to raise (largest: $4,813.61 more interest than the tier average (estimate)).
- Recommended next action
- Don't sign this quote as written. Ask for a corrected quote or compare other dealers.
What this means
This example deal has three problems worth fixing before signing: the payment is higher than the APR and term produce, more is being financed than the deal adds up to, and the APR is well above the average for prime credit.
Biggest issues:
- Amount financed is $836.12 more than the deal adds up to.
- Payment is $15.65/month higher than the math.
- APR 9.9% is 3.75 points above the prime average for new cars (6.15%).
Checklist
- Fix before signing
Amount financed is $836.12 more than the deal adds up to
Out-the-door $38,663.88 - down $3,000.00 = $35,663.88, but the contract finances $36,500.00. That gap is often products added in the finance office. Ask for every item that makes up the amount financed.
Estimated impact: $836.12 financed but not on the quote
Ask Dom: How to read a buyer's order · Ask Dom: Dealer financing, buy rate vs. your rate
- Fix before signing
Payment is $15.65/month higher than the math
$36,500.00 at 9.9% for 72 months is $674.35/month, but the quote says $690.00. The payment works out to 10.746% APR. That's a sign of payment packing (extra products or a higher rate built into the payment). Over the loan: $1,126.80.
Estimated impact: $1,126.80 extra paid over the loan (estimate)
Ask Dom: Dealer financing, buy rate vs. your rate · Ask Dom: How to read a buyer's order
- Fix before signing
APR 9.9% is 3.75 points above the prime average for new cars (6.15%)
Prime average new-car APR, Q2 2026: 6.15%. At 6.15%, you'd pay about $4,813.61 less interest over 72 months (estimate). Dealers can add a markup to the lender's "buy rate." Ask: "Is this the best rate you were approved for?" and bring a credit union pre-approval. Averages aren't offers; your rate depends on your full credit file, the car, and the term.
Estimated impact: $4,813.61 more interest than the tier average (estimate)
Experian: Average APR by credit tier, new / used (Experian, VantageScore 4.0) (Q2 2026) · Ask Dom: Dealer financing, buy rate vs. your rate · Ask Dom: Credit tiers and your rate
- Ask about it
Selling price is $500.00 over the sticker
Paying over MSRP is a markup you can negotiate. Compare out-the-door quotes from other dealers for the same vehicle.
Estimated impact: $500.00 over MSRP
- Ask about it
Nitrogen tires: $199.00
Nitrogen-filled tires. Optional dealer add-on. Ask that it be removed or not charged.
Estimated impact: $199.00 saved if you decline it
Ask Dom: How to read a buyer's order · Ask Dom: Negotiate the out-the-door price
- Ask about it
Paint & fabric protection: $899.00
Paint / fabric protection. Optional. Ask what's covered and for how long, and whether it's already applied. You can decline it.
Estimated impact: $899.00 saved if you decline it
Ask Dom: GAP and service contracts · Ask Dom: How to read a buyer's order
- Not enough info
Add the VIN for a recall check
Not enough info: the 17-character VIN is on the quote or the window sticker.
- Good to know
Doc fee: $225.00
Texas doc fee rule on file: No hard cap; $225 is the benchmark above which a dealer must justify the fee (secondary source). Where there's no cap, dealers rarely remove the fee, but you can ask for the same amount off the price.
Texas Comptroller, Motor Vehicle Tax Guide: total consideration (rebates and doc fees deducted) (accessed 2026-10-23) · 2026 state doc fee cap compilation (secondary source; confirm with the state) · Ask Dom: Negotiate the out-the-door price
- Looks right
The out-the-door total matches its lines
The lines add up to $38,663.88, the same as the quoted total.
- Looks right
Tax matches Texas rules
Expected about $2,256.13; the quote shows $2,256.13.
Texas Comptroller · Texas Comptroller, Motor Vehicle Tax Guide: total consideration (rebates and doc fees deducted) (accessed 2026-10-23) · Florida DOR, TIP 26A01-01: Motor Vehicle Sales Tax Rates by State (as of Feb 11, 2026)
Dollar figures are estimates from the numbers you entered. They can overlap (for example, an add-on can also be inside a packed payment), so don't add them up as a guaranteed saving.
Loan math
- Amount financed
- $36,500.00
- Term
- 72 months
- APR used
- 9.9%
- APR the payment works out to
- 10.746%
- Payment the math gives
- $674.35
What to say to the dealer
- I'm ready to buy today if we can get the paperwork right. Can you print me an itemized out-the-door buyer's order?
- I'm not paying over sticker. I'm comparing out-the-door quotes, and I'll buy where the number's right.
- Please remove Nitrogen tires, Paint & fabric protection. I'm not buying optional products today.
- The payment and amount financed are higher than this deal. I want to see the APR, term, and every item being financed, line by line.
- Is this the best rate you were approved for? I have a pre-approval, and I'll use it unless you can beat it.
Questions to ask
- What is included in the amount financed besides the car, tax, and fees?
- What was the lender's buy rate on my approval?
- Can I take the final paperwork home or have a few minutes to read it before signing?
Sources
- Ask Dom: How to read a buyer's order
- Texas Comptroller (2026-10-23)
- Texas Comptroller, Motor Vehicle Tax Guide: total consideration (rebates and doc fees deducted) (accessed 2026-10-23) (2026-10-23)
- Florida DOR, TIP 26A01-01: Motor Vehicle Sales Tax Rates by State (as of Feb 11, 2026) (2026-10-23)
- 2026 state doc fee cap compilation (secondary source; confirm with the state) (2026-10-23)
- Ask Dom: Negotiate the out-the-door price
- Ask Dom: GAP and service contracts
- Ask Dom: Dealer financing, buy rate vs. your rate
- Experian: Average APR by credit tier, new / used (Experian, VantageScore 4.0) (Q2 2026) (2026-08-27)
- Ask Dom: Credit tiers and your rate
- Ask Dom: How the Deal Check assessment works
AI can make mistakes, and so can paperwork. This report checks math and published rules; it isn't legal, tax, or financial advice. Double-check key numbers before you sign. Not sure? Book a 1-on-1 with Dom. Report version 2026-10-24, 2026-10-23.