Independent advice. We don't sell cars or loans. · Dom works in the car business
1-on-1 calls by appointmentFree ToolsContact

Deal Assessment

Is this a good car deal?

Enter the numbers from your buyer's order or lease worksheet. You get a Deal Assessment: every fee and tax checked for your state and county, the loan or lease math verified, add-ons flagged, a VIN recall check, and what to say to the dealer.

Check my quote, $69

Refund available if you email hello@askdomaboutcars.com within 3 days of purchase and haven't received your Deal Check results yet. Once your results are delivered, the sale is final, unless the check failed or couldn't be completed, in which case you get a free redo or a full refund. Refund policy

AI can make mistakes. Double-check key numbers before you sign. Not sure? Book a 1-on-1 with Dom.

See an example Deal Assessment first

Privacy: You pay on Stripe's secure page. We get your name, email, what you bought and the card's last 4 digits, never the full card number. How we handle this

Pick your state to see what's offered there. Advice-only for now: Dom reviews your deal and coaches you, and you negotiate yourself.

Not available in your state yet: paid services aren't available to buyers in Hawaii yet. The free calculators, state tax pages and starter guides are open to everyone.

Buy With Me notice: the hands-on Buy With Me service isn't offered in any state yet (it's waiting on an attorney's review). Calls with Dom and Deal Assessment · With Dom give you Dom's review and a plan, and you do the negotiating.

The math is done by code, not guessed by AI. The AI only writes a short plain-English summary of the checks, and it can't add numbers of its own. AI can make mistakes. Double-check key numbers before you sign. Not sure? Book a 1-on-1 with Dom.
Your dealDeal Assessment or AI Desk
Paste your quote to fill the fields (optional)

This fills the fields on your device; nothing is sent until you run the check. Leave out your SSN, date of birth, and account numbers. Photos and PDFs aren't supported yet; type or paste the numbers.

Deal type
Used to compare your APR with the average for your tier.

Price, fees and taxes

The total before down payment and trade.
Add-ons and dealer items (GAP, warranty, etch, nitrogen, protection packages, market adjustment)

Trade-in

Enter 0 if it's paid off.

Financing

Choosing between a rebate and a special APR? (optional)

Numbers stay on your device until you press Run. We keep a delivery record (when the report was delivered and viewed) for refunds, not your deal numbers. Privacy

Privacy: The numbers and notes you enter go to our server, which runs the checks; any notes are masked before our AI provider writes the summary. We don't store what you enter. How we handle this

Not legal, tax or financial advice. Educational only.

Privacy: You pay on Stripe's secure page. We get your name, email, what you bought and the card's last 4 digits, never the full card number. How we handle this

Example Deal Assessment

Here's what a report looks like, using made-up numbers for a financed SUV in Texas.

Example data. Made-up numbers to show what a report looks like. Not a real customer, dealer, or quote.

Deal Assessment Do not sign as written

Serious problems. Don't sign this as written.

2026 Example SUV · Financed purchase · new · Texas · Prime credit

3 to fix 3 to ask about 2 look right 1 need info

Negotiating room
3 items to raise (largest: $899.00 saved if you decline it).
Fees to challenge
Nothing flagged in what we could check.
Finance terms
3 items to raise (largest: $4,813.61 more interest than the tier average (estimate)).
Recommended next action
Don't sign this quote as written. Ask for a corrected quote or compare other dealers.

What this means

This example deal has three problems worth fixing before signing: the payment is higher than the APR and term produce, more is being financed than the deal adds up to, and the APR is well above the average for prime credit.

Biggest issues:

  • Amount financed is $836.12 more than the deal adds up to.
  • Payment is $15.65/month higher than the math.
  • APR 9.9% is 3.75 points above the prime average for new cars (6.15%).

Checklist

Dollar figures are estimates from the numbers you entered. They can overlap (for example, an add-on can also be inside a packed payment), so don't add them up as a guaranteed saving.

Loan math

Amount financed
$36,500.00
Term
72 months
APR used
9.9%
APR the payment works out to
10.746%
Payment the math gives
$674.35

What to say to the dealer

  1. I'm ready to buy today if we can get the paperwork right. Can you print me an itemized out-the-door buyer's order?
  2. I'm not paying over sticker. I'm comparing out-the-door quotes, and I'll buy where the number's right.
  3. Please remove Nitrogen tires, Paint & fabric protection. I'm not buying optional products today.
  4. The payment and amount financed are higher than this deal. I want to see the APR, term, and every item being financed, line by line.
  5. Is this the best rate you were approved for? I have a pre-approval, and I'll use it unless you can beat it.

Questions to ask

  • What is included in the amount financed besides the car, tax, and fees?
  • What was the lender's buy rate on my approval?
  • Can I take the final paperwork home or have a few minutes to read it before signing?

Sources

AI can make mistakes, and so can paperwork. This report checks math and published rules; it isn't legal, tax, or financial advice. Double-check key numbers before you sign. Not sure? Book a 1-on-1 with Dom. Report version 2026-10-24, 2026-10-23.

Assessment Method

You should know exactly how we reach a conclusion about your deal before you trust it. Every Deal Assessment covers four areas:

  • Negotiating room: the selling price against the sticker (MSRP), market adjustments, add-ons, rebates and your trade-in.
  • Fees to challenge: sales tax for your state and county, the doc fee against your state's cap, title and registration, and whether the out-the-door total adds up.
  • Finance terms: the real APR solved from your payment and compared with the average for your credit tier, the amount financed, and lease money factor, residual and rent charge.
  • Recommended next action: one clear step for you, from "Ready to sign" to "Do not sign as written".

How the recommended next action is set

  • Each line of your quote is marked Fix before signing (for example a tax overcharge, a doc fee over the state cap, a payment higher than the APR and term produce, more financed than the deal adds up to, or an APR more than 1.5 points above the average for your credit tier), Ask about it (optional add-ons count once as a group), or Looks right.
  • Every Deal Assessment starts at 100. Each Fix before signing item takes off 15 and each Ask about it item takes off 5. Looks right, information-only and "not enough info" lines take off nothing.
  • Ready to sign: 90 or more. Minor points to raise: 80 to 89. Negotiate before signing: 70 to 79. Resolve before signing: 60 to 69. Do not sign as written: under 60.
  • Limits: a payment, total or amount-financed mismatch means the result can't be better than "Negotiate before signing". If the dollars in Fix before signing items reach 10% or more of the price, it can't be better than "Resolve before signing".
  • More information needed: if fewer than 3 core checks can run, you get a list of what to add instead, and your Deal Check isn't used up.

APR benchmarks are Experian's average rates by credit tier (Q2 2026), and tax rules come from the same state and county tables as our car tax pages. Dollar impacts are estimates from your numbers. They can overlap, so don't add them up as a guaranteed saving. The math is done by code; the AI only writes the plain-English summary.

Assessment Method version 2026-10-24 (wording updated Nov. 5, 2026; the checks didn't change). AI can make mistakes, and so can paperwork. This isn't legal, tax, or financial advice.

Independent advice. We don't sell cars or loans. Dom works in the car business; we take no commissions from dealers, lenders or automakers. General education only, not financial or legal advice.