Independent advice. We don't sell cars or loans. · Dom works in the car business
1-on-1 calls by appointmentFree ToolsContact

Dealer financing vs. a bank or credit union: which costs less?

Dealer-arranged loans can be convenient, but the contract rate may sit above the buy rate. Compare with a bank or credit union pre-approval.

Updated 2026-11-05 · By Dom

Short answer

Dealer financing is when the dealership arranges your loan through a bank, credit union or automaker lender. A bank or credit union pre-approval gives you a real APR to beat. The contract rate can sit above the lender's buy rate. Compare APR and total cost, not the payment. Educational only; we're not a lender.

Free calculators for this: Dealer vs. bank rate calculator · Car payment calculator · Pre-approval readiness

Dealer financing vs. bank or credit union

How the two paths differ (CFPB / FTC)
Dealer-arranged financingBank or credit union loan
Who lendsA bank, credit union or automaker ("captive") lender the dealer submits you toYour own bank or credit union (direct lending)
Rate you seeThe contract rate on the retail installment contract; it can be higher than the lender's buy rateThe APR on your pre-approval or final loan offer
What to compareAPR, term, amount financed and total of payments in the Truth in Lending boxSame numbers on your pre-approval, then ask the dealer to beat them
Watch forRate markup (dealer reserve), add-ons rolled into the loan, a longer term dressed up as a "lower payment"Network or dealer-list limits on some lenders; expiration dates on pre-approvals

Sources: CFPB buy-rate explainer and FTC "Financing or Leasing a Car." We're not a lender and we don't make credit decisions.

What a rate markup costs (illustration)

Example only: $35,000 financed for 72 months. A 6.00% buy rate versus a 7.25% contract rate (1.25 points higher). Same math as the free dealer vs. bank rate calculator. Not a loan offer; your rate depends on your credit and the lender.

$35,000 for 72 months (illustration)
At 6.00% (buy rate)At 7.25% (contract rate)
Monthly payment$580.05$600.93
Total of payments$41,763.68$43,266.65
Total interest$6,763.68$8,266.65

That 1.25-point gap is about $21 a month, roughly $1,503 over the loan in this example. More on how markup works: dealer financing and the buy rate and dealer finance reserve.

How to compare before you sign

  1. Get a pre-approval from a bank or credit union so you have an APR, term and maximum amount in writing.
  2. Settle the out-the-door price first; don't lead with your rate or your target payment.
  3. Ask the dealer: "Is this the lowest rate the lender approved me for? Can you beat my pre-approval?"
  4. Compare APR, term, amount financed and total of payments on both offers, not just the monthly payment.
  5. Read the Truth in Lending box on the contract and make sure it matches what you agreed to.

Deal Assessment · Start here

Have a real quote? Get a Deal Assessment.

Deal Assessment · One Quote reads your actual quote: tax for your county, the doc fee, add-ons, and the real APR solved from your payment. Assessed line by line, with what to say. $69 one time.

Get my Deal Assessment · $69See an example Deal Assessment

Questions

Is dealer financing more expensive than a credit union?

Not always. Captive or special APR offers can beat an outside rate. The risk is a marked-up contract rate. A pre-approval shows you whether the dealer's offer is actually better.

What is a buy rate?

The lowest rate the lender approved for your credit profile when the dealer arranged the loan. The contract rate on your paperwork can be higher.

Should I tell the dealer my pre-approval rate?

Negotiate the out-the-door price first. Then ask them to beat your pre-approval at the same term, with no add-ons rolled in.

Are you a lender?

No. This page is educational. We don't make loans, quote rates for you, or decide credit.